Who, What, and How We Represent Matters.
Values-driven personal injury lawyers in Austin, Texas here to listen, educate, and help in any way we can.
Contact Us
Internal 2026 360

How to Negotiate an Insurance Settlement

In order to successfully negotiate a settlement in your accident injury case, you must protect yourself from insurance providers seeking to deny or devalue your claim. No matter how trustworthy an insurance adjuster may seem, the bottom line is that they represent a for-profit company that will attempt to avoid compensating you for the harms and losses you’ve experienced. Securing a positive outcome for your case requires leveraging knowledge and evidence to force the insurance provider to treat you fairly. 

Read on to learn how to gain leverage in these negotiations as well as how to determine whether you need to hire an accident injury lawyer. 

Understand Your Rights 

The tactics that insurance companies use to sweep the rug out from under you include making lowball offers, trying to force you into a premature settlement, or delaying the process until you run out of financial and emotional resources to continue challenging them. In these circumstances, holding your ground can be quite difficult — but knowing your legal rights can help you avoid making mistakes that will damage your case. 

Those who are most vulnerable in negotiations with insurance providers are those who do not understand their rights or the options available to them. Some accident victims fail to realize that they are not obligated to give a recorded statement right away, or that they are entitled to hire a lawyer before discussing anything about their case with insurance providers. 

Work Up a Damage Model

The more you know about what you deserve, the more the insurance company sees you as a risk — and insurance companies are willing to pay when they recognize a risk. You will need to work up a damage model, which essentially means figuring out what the law would force the company to pay were you to succeed in a trial. This involves calculating estimates for damages like medical expenses, past and future pain, physical impairment, mental anguish, and lost earnings or earning capacity. You will need to work closely with your medical providers and undergo all necessary testing so that you can understand your injuries and their long-term consequences. 

Contact an Accident Injury Lawyer

Negotiating with insurance providers requires the expertise to dodge their sophisticated tactics and apply pressure until they have no choice but to offer you a fair settlement. While anyone can act as their own representative in a personal injury case, it is difficult to manage such a fraught and complex situation without the help of a lawyer. We recommend getting in touch with a personal injury lawyer who will, at the very least, help you understand your legal rights and advise you on how to protect yourself. 

If you choose to hire that lawyer to represent you, they should do more than just manage negotiations on your behalf. They should confirm that you are receiving quality medical treatment, investigate the circumstances of your accident, preserve and obtain all evidence pertinent to your case, and allow you to focus on your recovery by offering you personal support in a stressful time.

Why FVF?

At FVF, we are committed to securing positive outcomes for our clients. We also want to equip anyone who may be unsure how to proceed with securing the resources they need to make informed decisions. In support of that goal, we offer free, no-pressure case consultations. During your consultation, we will discuss the unique circumstances of your case and the best strategy for securing fair financial recovery. 

No matter what step you decide to take after speaking with us, we hope to give you more clarity and confidence moving forward. Contact us today to schedule a free, remote consultation with an accident claim lawyer near you.

Latest Articles
Loss of Consortium Claims in Catastrophic Injury Cases  

In Texas, negligence and misconduct have consequences. Someone who gets injured by another person has the right to seek justice in the form of financial compensation for their related losses. This may include loss of…

Life Care Plans in Personal Injury Claims

Justice in a personal injury claim is not just about short-term medical bills—it’s about ensuring an injured person can afford the care, support, and resources they will need for the rest of their life. In…

Hypoxic Brain Injury Claims in Texas: Causes and Legal Options

When the brain is deprived of oxygen, even briefly, the consequences can be devastating. A hypoxic brain injury can result in permanent neurological damage, cognitive impairment, paralysis, or death. If oxygen deprivation occurred because of…

Understanding Traumatic Brain Injury Levels: Moderate to Severe

A moderate to severe traumatic brain injury (TBI) is often catastrophic. Unlike mild concussions, these injuries frequently result in long-term cognitive impairment, physical disability, or permanent life changes. If your injury resulted from a car…

How Much Is a Permanent Disability Lawsuit Worth in Texas?

In Texas, a lawsuit involving a catastrophic injury that results in permanent disability can lead to a jury verdict ranging from $100,000 to multiple millions of dollars, depending on the circumstances. The value of a…

Fourth-Degree Burns and When They Require Amputation

Burns can cause serious damage to the skin and layers of underlying tissues, muscles and even bones. A fourth-degree burn – the most severe type – may cause enough physical destruction to require a medically…

Expert Witnesses Needed in Catastrophic Injury Cases

If you suffer a catastrophic or life-altering injury in Texas, proving liability and full damages requires more than basic evidence. As the plaintiff, you carry the burden of proof. In complex cases involving paralysis, traumatic…

Analyzing Icy Road Crashes in Texas

Over the last decade, Texas has recorded more than 34,000 crashes during winter road conditions, including periods when roads were icy, snowy, or slushy. Those years include the historic February 2021 winter storm, referred to…

What Is the Average Settlement for a Spinal Cord Injury in Texas?

Spinal cord injury settlements in Texas can vary widely from case to case. For this reason, it is critical not to base the estimated value of your case on any “average” amount. Spine and back…

Loss of Consortium Claims in Catastrophic Injury Cases  

In Texas, negligence and misconduct have consequences. Someone who gets injured by another person has the right to seek justice in the form of financial compensation for their related losses. This may include loss of…

Life Care Plans in Personal Injury Claims

Justice in a personal injury claim is not just about short-term medical bills—it’s about ensuring an injured person can afford the care, support, and resources they will need for the rest of their life. In…

Hypoxic Brain Injury Claims in Texas: Causes and Legal Options

When the brain is deprived of oxygen, even briefly, the consequences can be devastating. A hypoxic brain injury can result in permanent neurological damage, cognitive impairment, paralysis, or death. If oxygen deprivation occurred because of…

Understanding Traumatic Brain Injury Levels: Moderate to Severe

A moderate to severe traumatic brain injury (TBI) is often catastrophic. Unlike mild concussions, these injuries frequently result in long-term cognitive impairment, physical disability, or permanent life changes. If your injury resulted from a car…

How Much Is a Permanent Disability Lawsuit Worth in Texas?

In Texas, a lawsuit involving a catastrophic injury that results in permanent disability can lead to a jury verdict ranging from $100,000 to multiple millions of dollars, depending on the circumstances. The value of a…